Tolkien Gateway

Talk:Boromir (Lord of Ladros)

[edit] Etymology

Temporarily moved statement from Boromir#Etymology:

The first element represents the stem [[BOR]], Q. ''voro-'', S. ''boro-, bro-'' meaning "ever, lasting, steady";<ref name=Ety353>{{LR|Etymologies}}, p. 353</ref> the ending ''-[[mir]]'' is an element meaning "jewel" in both languages, thus meaning "lasting jewel". The proper Sindarin form would perhaps be *''Borovír'' with [[lenition]].

Note that in the [[Appendix F]] ''Boromir'' is mentioned outside the names "remembered in the songs and histories of the First Age (as ''[[Beren]], [[Húrin]]'')" suggesting that Boromir was not named after the [[Boromir of Ladros]]. In the ''[[The Etymologies|Etymologies]]'' Boromir is said to derive from [[Old Noldorin]] ''[[Boronmíro]]'', being also a name originating from the [[Gnomes]].<ref name=Ety353/> --Morgan 15:45, 8 January 2011 (UTC)

[edit] Move?

Just by looking at the House of Beor category, this one's an odd one out. Wouldn't this be better at "Boromor (son of Boron)"? For that matter, how should we disambiguate people - by title, or by parentage, if known? --Ederchil (Talk/Contribs/Edits) 08:41, 23 June 2012 (UTC)

I'm not entirely sure. Perhaps this is one for a meeting?-- KingAragorn  talk  contribs  edits  email  23:13, 23 June 2012 (UTC)
The standard is usually "Person (Position)" and then if they don't have a position "Person (relation to another person)". If you look at Category:House of Elros or Category:Gondorians you can see this in operation. I don't think the principle is so much "You must go for parentage", but the principle is - in my opinion - "When disambiguating, use the most recognisable description to define the character."; in the cases of rulers it tends to be that they were a ruler and for others it tends to be the relationship to their parents. I think this is the sensible approach which is why we have:
Now, it may be in this case that I've got this one wrong - and I do remember wrangling over it - and that "Boromir (son of Boron)", "Boromir (Head of the House of Bëor)", "Boromir (House of Bëor)" or "Boromir (First Age man)" may be better ways of identifying him; I stuck with "Boromir (Lord of Ladros)" on the basis that the article was "Boromir of Ladros" and so there was a reasonable precedent there. Wikipedia goes with "Boromir (House of Bëor)"; EOA goes with "Boromir of Ladros", The Thain's Book went with "Boromir (Lord of the House of Beor)" and One Wiki went with "Boromir (House of Bëor)" (presumably copying Wikipedia). There isn't really a consensus on this one. --Mith (Talk/Contribs/Edits) 11:57, 30 June 2012 (UTC)