Tolkien Gateway

Tolkien Gateway:Meetings/1 April 2012

Tolkien Gateway Meetings
Sunday 1 April 2012, 8pm UTC, #Wiki IRC Channel
PST MST CST EST
12pm 1pm 2pm 3pm
GMT CET EET
8pm 9pm 10pm

[edit] Agenda and outcome

Item Responsible Member Discussion Point Outcome
#1 KingAragorn Meeting opening. Mith, Morgan, Gamling, and KingAragorn were all in attendance.
#2 KingAragorn Tolkien canon and TG canon policy (we need not decide anything, just discuss!) Those present agreed that we, as Tolkien Gateway contributors, can not make the judgement about whether or not a particular concept is canon or not except in the most obvious cases. The grey areas are what they are and this should be explained and made clear in the article (perhaps through a "Canonicity" section). Those present agreed that the current canoncity templates should be scrapped, with the non-canon template remaining only for concepts that are undoubtedly non-canon (such as concepts from adaptations).
#3 KingAragorn Adjournment discussions and meeting adjournment. The failure of the "Countdown to The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey" was noted. The only thing agreed was that editors should focus on the sections that pertain to The Hobbit.

[edit] Links