Tolkien Gateway

Talk:Inklings

[edit] Roger Lancelyn Green an Inkling?

I see that on this page (and the related template) Roger Lancelyn Green is included among the Inklings. None of the 'sources' (i.e. the further reading and the external links) mentioned give him as such. The MythSoc site says emphatically that he wasn't, and several of the books (at least The Inklings Handbook and The Company they keep) join in that.

So I feel that he should be taken out and, like Dorothy Sayers, mentioned as someone related by friendships (and a certain similarity in outlook) to the Inklings. -- Mithrennaith 00:07, 24 September 2008 (UTC)

This article (and most of the Inklings' individual) need some sort of upgrade/rewrite. I planned to do it some time ago, but kept postponing (en, van uitstel komt afstel). Currently, it has a rubbish layout, so it definately needs to be cleaned up. -- Ederchil (Talk/Contribs/Edits) 07:41, 24 September 2008 (UTC)